What Does The Government Provide?

Larrey Anderson writes a terrific column at American Thinker that everyone should read and think about titled ‘Stop and Think’:

Really. Stop and think. What does your government actually do for you? This article is a series of quick thought experiments to help answer that question.

First thought: Where are you physically situated? Unless someone has printed off this article and given it to you on paper, you are probably sitting in a room and reading the article on a computer screen.

Second thought: How many things can you find in this room that were created by the government? Let’s look around the room.

We will start with the words you are reading. An individual (me) wrote them. The words I have written appear on the computer screen you are viewing. The transmission system that sent the words to your computer was not invented or created (nor is it maintained) by the government. (Al Gore’s claim to be the inventor of the Internet notwithstanding.)

None of the components of either the monitor or the computer that allow you to read these words were invented or created by the government.

The screen probably sits on a desk. The plastic, wood, varnish, vinyl, and screws in the desk were all manufactured by privately owned businesses. Private citizens designed the desk. Non-governmental employees built the desk.

Unless you are reading outside from a laptop, you are still sitting in that room. The sheetrock on the walls of the room was produced by a private company. The walls were installed, finished, and painted by individual hired laborers.

Glance at the door to the room. Same story. The door and its hardware were all privately invented, manufactured, and mounted.

In short, nothing tangible in the room is a “gift” from the government. Not one thing. (This is true even if you happen to work for the government and are situated in a government owned building. All of the work on the building was subcontracted. All of the items in the building were privately produced.)

Third thought: Are there things you can locate in the room that are a “gifts” from the government? Sure there are. Lots of them.

Let’s run through the things in the room again. We will start with my written words.

Unless my words incite or threaten some form of violence they are, for the moment, free from government regulation.

When we move to the transmission system that gets my words to your screen the “gifts” from the government start to appear. The behind the scenes tussle for broadband access has greased the hands of lots of politicians. And, rest assured, in the future it will grease a lot more. The government taxes, monitors, and regulates the transmission (not, at this point in time, the content) of the information you are now reading.

How about that monitor you are looking at — and the computer? There are literally thousands of government regulations on each of them. The rules state, as examples, how much energy the products can use, what chemicals can (or cannot) be used in the manufacturing process, and how to throw the computer in the trash (if you are using VISTA).

The desk and chair where you sit? The government regulates those as well.

Not the walls. Surely the government has nothing to do with the regulation of the walls? It does. And the door. And the door handle.

The government does not make any of the things you see around you … but it regulates every one of them.

Fourth thought: Is this regulation necessary? Arguments can be made for the government’s requirements for each of the items in the room. Some of the arguments might even be good ones. Some governmental requirements might make these items safer to use. Every requirement makes them more expensive to buy and to maintain.

Fifth thought: Exactly what does the government give us? It is important to understand, as you look around the room, that the government has nothing to do with the provision of the goods and services of the things that you see. Government has everything to do with the regulation of those goods and services.

Sixth thought: The next time an elected representative of your government tells you that he is going to make your life better, or fix the economy, or make America great again, ask yourself one question: How?

I cannot thank Mr. Anderson enough for writing this! This column is a perfect illustration of the difference between capitalism and socialism.

Capitalism is the free market system in which goods and services are produced and consumed because people want them. Profit and success drive the system, which benefits both parties of each transaction – one person gets a product or service that he or she wants, the other gets paid for providing it. It’s mutually beneficial, and everyone wins.

Socialism is an oppressive system in which the government controls everything, distributing goods and services as it sees fit (remember how taxation was all about ‘fairness‘?). It does nothing to enhance freedom, prosperity, or success; rather, it does the opposite. Socialism is parasitic. It does nothing to produce or contribute to the health and success off of its host organism — in this case America — but it leeches the strength, ingenuity, and motivation out of it.

This is what we are going to learn the hard way over the next few years. The brand of socialism that Obama wants to implement in America (according to his own promises) is going to tax the most successful people in this country, the vast majority of small businesses (who provide the vast majority of jobs) in this country, and implement vast new restrictions and regulations on every aspect of life. We are going to see an unprecedented attack on the American way of life, and it is sadly going to come from our own leaders.

Just remember this illustration as you see more regulation and less freedom – as you read these words, there is absolutely nothing around you that the government has produced, created, or provided. In contrast, almost everything around you has been taxed, restricted, or regulated by the government.

Now, what do you think government is going to do for you in the next 2-4 years? That’s what Obama promised, and that’s what 62 million people voted for. Now we’re all going to get it.

There’s my two cents.


I'm a gun-owning, Bible-thumping, bitter clinger conservative in the heartland. You can disagree with me if you want (you do, after all, have a right to be wrong)...just don't be rude or stupid and we'll get along just fine! :)

Posted in General Politics, Leaning Left

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow me on Twitter

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 95 other followers

%d bloggers like this: